What to Do When Someone Doesn't Return Your Property: Legal Rights and Using the Criminal Justice System

Legal rights and using the criminal justice system for unreturned property

‍

Lending your personal property, such as a car, camera, or phone, often involves a significant amount of trust.

‍

Unfortunately, there are instances when the person who borrows your property does not return it as agreed.

‍

This situation can be frustrating and distressing. However, understanding your legal rights and the steps you can take within the criminal justice system can help you recover your property. Here's what to do in such scenarios, including your legal remedies available and the role of the criminal justice system.

‍

read: How to Get Someone to Pay You Back

‍

Understanding Your Legal Rights

When someone doesn't return your property, it typically falls under the legal concepts of conversion or civil theft. Here are some key legal terms to understand:

1. Conversion: This is an act of unauthorized use or control over someone else's property, depriving the owner of its use. If someone refuses to return your property, they may be committing conversion.
2. Civil Theft: This refers to the unlawful taking of someone else's property with the intent to permanently deprive the owner of it. If the person who borrowed your property intends not to return it, this could constitute theft.
3. Breach of Contract: If you have a written or verbal agreement specifying the return of the property, failing to return it may also be considered a breach of contract.

‍

Steps to Recover Your Property

1. Request the Return: The first step is always to request the return of your property. This can be done informally through a phone call, message, or in person. Ensure you document these requests as they may be useful later.
2. Send a Formal Demand Letter: If informal requests fail, a formal demand letter is a more serious step. This letter should detail the property in question, the terms of the agreement, and a clear demand for its return by a specified date. Sending this letter via certified mail can provide proof that the request was made.
3. File a Police Report: If the person continues to refuse to return your property, filing a police report is a logical next step. Theft or conversion of property is a criminal offense, and involving law enforcement can sometimes prompt the return of the property.
4. Small Claims Court: If the value of the property is within the limit for small claims court in your jurisdiction, you can file a lawsuit there. This process is generally quicker and less expensive than other court proceedings. You will need to provide evidence that the property was loaned and that the person has refused to return it.
5. Civil Lawsuit: For higher-value items or more complex cases, you may need to file a civil lawsuit. This will typically involve hiring an attorney and can be a more time-consuming and expensive process. However, it may be necessary to recover valuable property.
6. Using Mediation: Before resorting to court, consider mediation. A neutral third party can help negotiate the return of your property, often avoiding the need for a formal legal battle.

‍

Utilizing the Criminal Justice System

When dealing with unreturned property, involving the criminal justice system can be an effective measure. Here’s how:

1. Criminal Complaint: As mentioned, you can file a police report. Provide all necessary details, including any communications you’ve had with the person, the terms of the agreement, and the value of the property.
2. Investigation: The police will investigate the complaint. This might include contacting the person who has your property and attempting to recover it on your behalf.
3. Pressing Charges: If the investigation finds sufficient evidence, the police may press charges for theft or conversion. The person who has your property may face criminal charges, which could include fines or even jail time.
4. Restitution: In some cases, the criminal court may order the return of the property or financial restitution to compensate for your loss.‍

‍

Conclusion

When someone fails to return your property, understanding your legal rights and the options available within the criminal justice system is crucial. Start with direct communication and escalate to formal demand letters and police reports if necessary. Small claims court or a civil lawsuit can be effective for recovering valuable property, and mediation offers an alternative to litigation. By taking these steps, you can increase your chances of recovering your property and ensuring your rights are protected. At Law Passport, we are here to guide you through these processes and help you achieve a resolution.